While we choose our leaders, Washington is setting the rules

By Gregorie Michael Towai (Eipéráng)
As a Refaluwasch son of the Marianas, I understand the ocean as a source of ancestry, navigation, sustenance, knowledge, and responsibility. Our Chamorro relatives, whose ancestral homeland is the Marianas, share an equally profound, though distinct, relationship with these islands and surrounding waters. For both Indigenous peoples, decisions affecting our environment are inseparable from our cultural heritage, livelihoods and responsibilities to future generations.
During the November 2026 elections, our communities debated leadership, electricity costs, employment, and the Commonwealth’s future. Families wanted to know who could improve their daily lives and whether campaign promises would translate into meaningful results.
But while voters were choosing their representatives, Congress was considering changes to federal rules that those representatives and the communities they serve may have to live with.
The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026, or BAAJA (S. 5653), proposes substantial changes to federal permitting and environmental review. Its implications reach directly into the concerns raised during our elections: affordable energy, responsible investment, environmental protection, and public accountability.
The CNMI and Guam need dependable infrastructure and sustainable economic opportunities. Families struggling with electricity costs deserve practical improvements. Yet the need for development should not require communities to surrender meaningful participation in decisions affecting their environment.
Two provisions warrant particular attention.
Section 1110, as introduced, would establish a 150-day deadline for certain legal challenges involving compliance with the National Environmental Policy Act. It would also impose requirements regarding prior public comment participation and restrict the remedies courts could provide for certain violations.
Section 1401, as introduced, would restrict federal agencies’ ability to revoke, suspend, or modify covered permits and authorizations, subject to specified exceptions. A subsequent manager’s amendment revised aspects of these provisions, although concerns about the scope of judicial review and the ability to modify federal approvals remain subjects of legislative debate.
For island communities, the central question is practical: Can residents obtain information, understand technical findings, organize a meaningful response and secure legal assistance before their opportunities for review expire?
A legal right is of limited value when the people most affected cannot realistically exercise it.
ADVERTISEMENT

These concerns are particularly relevant to the Marianas, where communities are confronting overlapping questions involving military expansion, environmental review, and proposed seabed mineral development.
These activities do not all operate under the same laws or permitting processes. Military training proposals, mineral activities in waters near the Marianas, and mining applications in international waters require distinct legal analyses.
Nevertheless, each raises questions about transparency, cumulative environmental impacts, cultural protection and meaningful public participation.
The Refaluwasch Journal of Knowledge and Culture has addressed these issues through institutional commentary, coalition participation, and correspondence concerning federal environmental decision-making.
ADVERTISEMENT
RJKC also participated as one of 18 community-based amici in Department of the Air Force v. Prutehi Guåhan, through an amicus brief coordinated by Right to Democracy concerning environmental review and hazardous-munitions disposal activities in Guam.
That experience reinforces a broader institutional concern: communities must retain meaningful opportunities to question federal decisions, obtain judicial review where authorized, and ensure that environmental safeguards are enforceable.
ADVERTISEMENT
For Refaluwasch and Chamorro communities, the stakes extend beyond conventional economic calculations. Our relationships with land and sea carry histories, responsibilities, and knowledge that cannot always be measured through federal permitting schedules.
Congress should preserve meaningful Tribal consultation where legally applicable while also ensuring that Indigenous communities in the territories have appropriate opportunities to participate in decisions affecting their homelands.
Our elected officials have corresponding responsibilities. They should explain how they will obtain independent expertise, communicate federal proposals to residents, and represent territorial concerns when decisions affecting our waters are made in Washington.
There are legitimate reasons to improve permitting. Better agency coordination, sufficient staffing, accessible information, and realistic review schedules can reduce unnecessary delays.
But faster decisions are not automatically better decisions.
Reform should preserve meaningful cultural consultation, appropriate judicial remedies, and agencies’ capacity to respond to significant new evidence.
I urge Congress to examine and revise provisions that could weaken those safeguards. I also encourage our elected leaders to make federal permitting reform a matter of sustained public discussion rather than allowing it to remain an issue addressed primarily in Washington.
Choosing our leaders matters. So does protecting their ability, and ours, to question decisions that could shape the Marianas for generations.
Gregorie Michael Towai (Eipéráng) is a native Refaluwasch son of the CNMI, an independent researcher, a published author, the founder of the Refaluwasch Journal of Knowledge and Culture, and a Co-Founder of Islander Connect. His work focuses on Indigenous knowledge systems, environmental stewardship, governance, cultural preservation, and the future of Oceania.
Views expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of the Pacific Island Times.








