A broader conversation about reducing the risk of conflict


A recent report by Jennifer Kavanagh, senior fellow and director of Military Analysis at Defense Priorities, has brought renewed attention to the debate over the future of U.S. military posture in the Indo-Pacific.
Her proposal for what she calls a “second island chain strategy” suggests shifting certain U.S. military capabilities away from more exposed positions along the first island chain and toward locations farther from potential areas of conflict, including Guam and other locations across the Pacific.
The proposal raises an important question for the people of Guam and the wider Pacific region: How can the United States and its partners reduce the risk of conflict while ensuring that communities throughout the region remain safe, secure and resilient?
While the proposal is intended, among other objectives, to reduce the risk of a major conflict with China, the broader discussion should not be viewed simply as a choice between positioning military forces closer to or farther from China and Taiwan. Nor should Guam’s security concerns be understood primarily through the lens of cross-Strait tensions.
The security of Guam, Taiwan and the wider Indo-Pacific is shaped by a much broader range of factors, including China’s growing military assertiveness, regional strategic competition, deterrence and the resilience of communities throughout the Pacific. These interconnected challenges deserve a broader conversation—one that recognizes the importance of maintaining peace and stability while strengthening the security and resilience of the entire region.
Discussions about shifting U.S. military forces toward Guam inevitably raise questions about the relationship between regional security and cross-Strait tensions.
ADVERTISEMENT
However, it is important not to conflate these issues or suggest that Guam’s security challenges are primarily caused by tensions across the Taiwan Strait. In reality, security challenges in the Pacific are shaped by multiple factors, including broader strategic competition, military planning, economic interests, and the resilience of communities throughout the region. In fact, China has emerged as the most significant source of risk to regional security, with its increasingly assertive behavior across the East China Sea, the South China Sea, the Taiwan Strait and the waters surrounding Taiwan.
Its persistent gray-zone coercion, military intimidation, and attempts to unilaterally change the status quo have heightened tensions and undermined peace and stability across the Indo-Pacific.
These actions underscore the need for continued vigilance and coordinated responses among regional partners. Taiwan, by contrast, remains committed to maintaining peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait and preserving the status quo. If the goal is to reduce the risk of conflict, Taiwan’s own efforts to preserve peace and stability should also be part of the conversation.
For the people of Taiwan, peace across the Taiwan Strait is not an abstract strategic concept—it is the condition that allows families to live in security, businesses to operate, and communities to plan for the future. Taiwan’s consistent policy has been to maintain peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait and preserve the status quo, reflecting its fundamental interest in preventing conflict.
That commitment requires proactive preparedness. Taiwan is strengthening its self-defense capabilities and whole-of-society resilience, including its ability to maintain essential public services and respond effectively during crises. Taiwan views this readiness not as a posture of aggression, but as a vital means of reducing vulnerability, deterring coercion and preserving peace.
A society’s ability to protect its people and sustain vital infrastructure in times of emergency should not be misinterpreted as an intention to provoke conflict.
ADVERTISEMENT

This carries a broader lesson for Guam as well. Security cannot be measured solely by where military forces are deployed; it is equally defined by whether hospitals remain operational, communications and transportation networks remain functional, emergency services can respond effectively and communities can recover from unexpected disasters.
Taiwan and Guam share many of these vulnerabilities. As Pacific island communities, both are regularly exposed to typhoons and other natural hazards.
Building on a longstanding relationship grounded in economic development, healthcare, education, and cultural exchanges, both sides would benefit from expanded practical cooperation, particularly in healthcare, disaster preparedness, humanitarian assistance and capacity-building to strengthen community resilience.
Such practical cooperation does not replace strategic security planning; rather, it complements it by strengthening the communities that would ultimately be affected by a crisis.
The debate over a “second island chain” strategy is therefore worth having. Peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait are matters of global concern, as any conflict would have far-reaching consequences for international trade, critical supply chains and global technological development.
Calls for the United States to abandon Taiwan overlook the strategic costs of allowing coercion to succeed and the broader international stakes, as maintaining peace and stability in the Taiwan Strait serves the interests of the United States and the world.
The key question is how governments and communities can reduce the likelihood of conflict while also making the Pacific better prepared for the challenges of an uncertain security environment. Taiwan believes that responsible self-defense, resilience and practical cooperation all have a role to play.
For the people of Guam, Taiwan fully appreciates why discussions regarding the Taiwan Strait naturally prompt questions about Guam’s own security. At the same time, it is important to recognize that Guam’s security is shaped by a broad range of regional and local factors, not simply by developments across the Taiwan Strait.
This conversation can—and should—move beyond military force posture to examine what Taiwan, Guam, and other Pacific communities can accomplish together to mitigate risks, strengthen resilience and ensure our shared region remains a thriving place to live, work and prosper.
That is a conversation Taiwan is ready to be part of.
Chia-ping Liu is the director general of TECO in Guam.
Subscribe to
our digital
monthly issue








