Facebook: US territories aren't part of the US
The immediate result is that you can't use its charitable
donation tools. Equally American is calling them out
Way to go, Mark Zuckerberg! As if Facebook doesn't have enough problems, your team is dissing millions of Americans outside the U.S. mainland.
According to Facebook, the nearly 4 million Americans living in U.S. territories do not live in the “United States.” Instead, Guam, the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands and American Samoa are each treated as being a separate foreign country. As a result, on FB's #GivingTuesday, residents of U.S. territories will be unable to use Facebook’s charitable donation tools to support their favorite charities.
For Equally American, a nonprofit advocacy organization working to end the second class treatment of Americans living in U.S. territories, Facebook’s "discriminatory practices both perpetuate misconceptions about U.S. territories and restrict its ability to fundraise on #GivingTuesday."
“Facebook’s entry into nonprofit fundraising has a lot to like, with zero fees and a $7 million matching program with Paypal on #GivingTuesday. But it’s hard to miss the irony of how Facebook’s unequal treatment of Americans in U.S. territories makes it harder for our nonprofit to bring an end to unequal treatment in U.S. territories,” said Neil Weare, president and founder of Equally American.
“Facebook has been an important part of our advocacy toolkit, making it easier to build community across five territories and a diaspora that extends throughout the 50 states. But the inability of our supporters in U.S. territories to use Facebook’s contribution tools really limits what we’re able to achieve using its platform,” Weare added.
Equally American is currently litigating the question of whether U.S. territories are in “the United States” for purposes of the Citizenship Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, challenging discriminatory federal laws that deny birthright citizenship in certain U.S. territories.
Equally American’s Giving Tuesday campaign on Facebook seeks to raise $10,000 in support of its advocacy. With Facebook and Paypal’s match, this would mean $20,000 in overall support – a significant boost for a small nonprofit. But the limits Facebook places on contributors from U.S. territories make it substantially more difficult for Equally American to reach its goal. Unable to contribute to Equally American through Facebook, residents of U.S. territories must instead donate directly through the nonprofit’s own website. This means 2.2% in Paypal processing fees, and exclusion from Facebook and Paypal’s $7 million matching program.
Facebook’s matching program starts at 8 a.m. ET on Tuesday, Nov. 27, 2018, which is 9 a.m. in Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands, 11 p.m. in Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands, and 2 a.m. in American Samoa.
Responding to an inquiry about Facebook’s discrimination against users in U.S. territories, Facebook Support responded “we know this is frustrating and disappointing to people in Guam and other areas where are tools aren’t available, but [we] continue to work with partners to expand to other areas as quickly as possible.”
Delegate Madeleine Bordallo, who represents Guam as a non-voting Member of Congress, said: “It is an injustice that Americans living in the U.S. territories are not treated as other Americans living in the states. Facebook is supposed to be about ‘bringing the world closer together.’ But treating residents of Guam and other U.S. territories as living outside the United States and excluding them from programs like the #GivingTuesday match perpetuates misconceptions and injustices that have long had a negative impact on our communities. I hope that they will reverse this decision and allow Guam residents, and those of the other U.S. territories, to be treated similar to other Americans in the 50 states.”
Russell Pate, a supporter of Equally American and former President of the U.S. Virgin Islands Bar Association, demonstrated in a video how Facebook’s contribution tool doesn’t work in the U.S. Virgin Islands, explaining his concern about “pervasive discrimination that starts at the government and then actually goes down into the private sector. It’s very unfortunate to be treated as a second-class citizen.” He added: “Every American citizen should have the same rights and same opportunities.”
Delegate Stacey Plaskett, who represents the U.S. Virgin Islands as a non-voting Member of Congress, reacted to this latest discrimination against residents of U.S. territories by saying, “In the scheme of things, Facebook’s discrimination against Virgin Islanders on #GivingTuesday pales in comparison to the discrimination we face every day in federal programs like Medicaid. But no American should be discriminated against simply because of where they live, whether it’s by the federal government or a private sector entity like Facebook.”