Court blocks US government's seabed lease auction in American Samoa

By Mar-Vic Cagurangan
The National Marine Fisheries Service violated the Endangered Species Act when it greenlit the deep-sea mining lease sale off American Samoa, a federal court in Hawaii ruled on Nov. 16, four days before the scheduled auction of two seabed areas totaling more than 31 million acres.
Despite the court ruling, the Marine Minerals Administration has not canceled the Nov. 19 auction in California, which would be the first deep-sea mining lease sale in the United States.
The second lease sale involving the waters of the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam is tentatively scheduled for Dec. 19. It faces a similar lawsuit.
Granting Earthjustice's petition for summary judgment, U.S. District Court Judge Jill Otake invalidated the U.S. government's conclusion that the sale “is not likely to adversely affect” any protected species.
The court found the consultation entirely failed to evaluate the effects of post-leasing mineral exploration and mining.
"Although for now these leases would only authorize the lease holder to conduct preliminary surveying activity, they may eventually allow the lease holder to develop marine minerals from polymetallic nodules collected from the ocean floor—so-called deep-sea mining," the court said.
Earthjustice filed the lawsuit on Aug. 18, on behalf of Faʻasao Amerika Samoa and Conservation Council for Hawaiʻi, challenging the Trump administration’s rush to open our oceans to deep-sea mining in U.S. waters.
ADVERTISEMENT

Noting the MMA's argument that the proposed action was "limited to the lease sales themselves," the court pointed out that the agency did not analyze any effects from post-leasing conduct, including exploration, testing, development, or actual mining on leases.
The court found that the Fisheries Service's “cramped, expedited, informal consultation is apparently unprecedented in the context of leasing" and that its failure to consider the entire action violates the Endangered Species Act.
ADVERTISEMENT

“We are relieved by this ruling. Plans for deep seabed mining must assess and prevent harm to endangered species, many of which are sacred to the Samoan people,” said Seumalu Dr. Elora Raymond, cofounder of Fa’asao Amerika Samoa.
Jonee Peters, executive director of the Conservation Council for Hawai‘i, said the decision underscored the importance of protecting marine species and ecosystems.
"Keeping this marine ecosystem pristine and intact is vital and should not be harmed by any speculative industry,” Peters added.
Chris Eaton, Earthjustice attorney, said the ruling "is a win for communities in American Samoa, as well as the whales, sharks and sea turtles.
"It recognizes that the law requires the government to understand the full repercussions of its actions before letting this untested industry destroy one of the most pristine parts of the ocean on the planet,” Eaton said.

John Wasko, executive director of the American Samoa Development Council and an advocate of deep-sea mining, defended the emerging industry, saying it offers a solution to climate change.
"Seabed mining will disrupt a tiny portion of ocean floor expanse. No one is disputing that fact," he said. "That minuscule environmental disruption is the price humanity will pay for environmental survival of the earth’s atmosphere."
He criticized opponents of deep-sea mining for failing "to recognize their own guilty pleasures," arguing that "driving an internal combustion engine automobile, working in an air-conditioned space, or using a solid-state memory device all contribute to the anthropogenic destruction of planet Earth’s atmosphere."
"Those same anti-seabed critical mineral extraction opponents need to recognize their part in climate change and Earth's atmosphere warming," Wasko said. "They want their environmental agenda enforced without recognizing they themselves are the guilty parties."
Subscribe to
our digital
monthly issue







